Golf Course Review & Scouting Report

Buck Hill Falls Golf Club

76

Buck Hill Falls, Pennsylvania

Established
1907
Architect
Robert White (1907 original), Donald Ross (1922 expansion), Rees Jones/Andrew Mutch/NMP Golf Construction (2022 restoration)
Access
Public
Par
Par 72
Length
4,890 – 6,569 yds
Green Fees
$
The verdict

Ross-Inspired Mountain Tradition

Buck Hill Falls delivers a century-old test through rolling Pocono terrain, blending Donald Ross’s architectural touch with rugged mountain character. Recent restoration highlights smart, shot-maker’s golf and a historic atmosphere welcoming to everyday visitors. It’s an ideal anchor for a Northeast golf trip in the Poconos.

Course DNA
Difficulty
73
Scenery
81
Conditioning
74
Shot Variety
78
Walkability
68
Green Complexity
76
Wow Factor
71
Design Quality
81
Don't miss

Be sure to walk the upstairs clubhouse balcony for panoramic mountain views before or after your round.

At a glance

Quick facts

Total holes
27 (three 9s: Red, White, Blue)
Recent restoration
2022 by Rees Jones/Mutch/NMP
Course elevation
Approx. 1,600 ft in Pocono Mountains
Oldest 9-hole layout
Robert White, 1907
Classic architect
Donald Ross (18 holes, 1922)
Dress code
No jeans; shoes in locker room
Practice facilities
Driving range, putting green
Historic role
White was first PGA of America president
The design

The architecture

Buck Hill Falls Golf Club marries Donald Ross’s routing genius to rolling Pocono mountain land, with the Red nine offering Robert White’s original 1907 footprint. The 2022 restoration recaptured Ross’s challenging but playable green surrounds, faithful bunkering, and the historic blend of woodland corridors and open mountain views. Strategy, not power, is king here: golfers face elevation changes, demanding angles, and sloped lies that reward creativity and nerve. The three nines seamlessly interweave for distinctive loops that all echo a century of golf tradition.

Both Donald Ross and Robert White left lasting marks on the course, and the faithful 2022 restoration by Rees Jones and team has brought their original intent to life for modern golfers.

Defining features
  • Terrain-following mountain routing
  • Restored Ross bunkering and green complexes
  • Classic Ross false fronts and approach options
  • Sharp elevation changes across holes
  • Distinctive mix of open and wooded corridors
Hole by hole

Signature holes

Hole 4

Pocono Highlands Ascent

PAR
5
YARDAGE
563

The sweeping par-5 4th climbs steadily along the mountain, challenging players to manage both distance and direction. Its elevation gain and length make it a demanding par, even for big hitters. An aggressively shaped layup sets up a tricky approach to a perched green.

Play it smart

Think three shots and prioritize fairway placement on each, especially if your drive doesn’t catch the downslope.

Where it bites

Steep hillside rough and challenging bunkers swallow loose approaches and force a precise third.

Course management

Shots to think about

Approaching an elevated green with a back-to-front slope
Take an extra club, but err short to leave an uphill chip rather than risking a tough downhill putt.
Facing a tight mountain fairway surrounded by trees
Club down and aim for the heart to avoid being blocked by dense timber.
Long irons into the 9th or 14th green
Focus on tempo and direction—missing short often yields an easier recovery than long.
Managing mountain-side doglegs
Trust the fairway’s tilt and play your shape to work with the natural slope.
Short par 4s like 11
Resist the driver; playing for position sets up the easiest approach.
Strong crosswinds in the mountain valleys
Commit fully—partial swings are punished, so pick your line and execute with conviction.
On the day

What to expect

Conditions

Well-maintained, classic Northeast conditioning with quick-recovering turf and restored greens.

Vibe

A tradition-soaked, refined mountain-club atmosphere open to the public.

Dress code

No jeans; change shoes in locker room; collared shirt required.

Before you tee off

Your game plan

01

Brush up on mountain lies

Practice uneven stances and playing from sloped fairways ahead of time.

02

Bring layers

Mountain weather can change quickly—mornings are cool and afternoons warm up fast.

03

Check tee setup

The course offers three nines—confirm your loop and routing at check-in.

04

Leave extra time

The mountain terrain and possible traffic in Poconos towns mean early arrival is wise.

The lore

How it came to be

  1. 1907

    Original course (Red 9) opened by Robert White

  2. 1922

    Donald Ross-designed Blue and White nines debut

  3. 1928

    White reworks Red to integrate with Ross nines

  4. 2022

    Full restoration of Ross nines by Rees Jones and team

  5. 2022

    Centennial celebration of Ross course opening

Stories & legends

What makes it special

architecture

Ross’s Mountain Masterpiece

Donald Ross brought his signature strategic shaping to the mountain slopes, expanding Buck Hill Falls into a masterfully routed 27-hole experience. Every approach demands careful club selection and attention to angle, with mountain breezes and classic greens adding depth to every round.

heritage

The PGA’s First President

Robert White, the club’s founding designer, became the very first president of the PGA of America, forever linking Buck Hill Falls to the roots of American professional golf. His influence shaped not just this club, but the standards of the sport nationwide.

restoration

A Return to Ross

After a century in play, Buck Hill Falls debuted a head-to-toe restoration in 2022, led by Rees Jones, Andrew Mutch, and NMP Golf Construction. The team revived the classic bunkering and green contours, restoring Ross’s vision for the next generation.

For the group chat

Fun facts

1

Designer Robert White became the first president of the PGA of America.

2

The Red nine’s origin makes it one of the oldest courses in continuous play in Pennsylvania.

3

Buck Hill Falls celebrated the Ross course's centennial in 2022 with a major restoration.

4

The club maintains a strict dress code rooted in its century-old traditions.

Build the trip

If you're making a Poconos golf escape

CourseAccessWhy it's on the listTrip
Woodloch Springs
Resort

Top-tier mountain golf with public access, strong complement to Buck Hill’s classic style.

Hideaway Hills Golf Club
Public

Challenging, scenic, and affordable mountain golf less than 45 minutes away.

Jack Frost National Golf Club
Resort

Fun resort option with ski-area views and broad fairways.

Great Bear Golf Club
Semi-Private

Nicklaus design and top-ranked Poconos test for the architecturally curious.

Book lodging in the Mount Pocono, Cresco, or Stroudsburg area for short commutes to Buck Hill Falls and regional golf courses.

Course DNA

If You Like Buck Hill Falls Golf Club

Courses with the most similar DNA profile — matched by deviation shape across all eight playing characteristics.

The architect's other work

More from Donald Ross

Aronimink Golf Club

Newtown Square, PA

Host of PGA and BMW Championships

Oak Hill Country Club (East)

Rochester, NY

Frequent PGA Championship venue

Pinehurst No. 2

Pinehurst, NC

Ross masterpiece, U.S. Open venue

From the community

Community Sentiment

See something inaccurate in this listing?