Hartsdale, New York
Scarsdale Golf Club is a time-honored private track with genuine architectural pedigree from Tillinghast and deep club history, best experienced as a favored destination for members and lucky guests. Its reputation centers on demanding placement and disciplined play, surrounded by mature trees and rolling Westchester land—the quintessential private New York member experience. Not a national or regional travel magnet, but a proud stronghold for classic, competitive golf.
Step into the main clubhouse lounge and look for the historic photos of golf legends Vardon, Ray, Hagen, and Jones, who played early exhibitions at the club.
Scarsdale’s essence is pure Tillinghast: firm, thoughtful routing across rolling, wooded land, with each hole tailored to its natural contours rather than bent to formula. The mix of challenging long par 4s, risk-reward par 5s, and inviting but tricky par 3s exemplifies classic Golden Age strategy, especially as tree lines, elevation shifts, and well-defended greens subtly shape the battle from tee to green. Though succinct in total yardage, the course forces accuracy, poise, and creative shotmaking—a member’s test built to endure.
A.W. Tillinghast oversaw the major redesign in the early 1920s, fusing Westchester’s natural shapes with his hallmark strategic vision.
Stretched to 545 yards, this is the longest hole at Scarsdale and a pivotal scoring opportunity. A wide fairway tempts power hitters but requires precision to set up any thoughts of reaching in two.
Choose between aggressive placement off the tee and a tactical lay-up for a favored distance; the uphill approach puts a premium on angle.
Miss wide off the tee or push the second shot too far and thick rough plus subtle greenside slopes await.
Prim, well-kept fairways and classically contoured greens; expect a polished private-club test.
Efficient, four-hour rounds are the member standard.
Traditional, understated, golf-centric Westchester clubhouse culture.
Private club attire required; collared shirts and golf slacks recommended.
Precision off the tee and approach is more valuable than sheer distance throughout the round.
With several risk/reward short par 4s and demanding greens, up-and-down skills are vital.
Moderate elevation shifts in the routing mean some uneven lies; soft spikes and comfortable shoes are a plus.
A quick study of Tillinghast green complexes and recovery strategies will pay dividends here.
Club founded with Willie Dunn designing the original nine holes.
Current clubhouse constructed.
Historic clubhouse receives major renovation.
Rather than impose a template, Tillinghast routed Scarsdale through the natural Westchester hills, making every hole fit its unique pocket of land. Local lore holds that his design was executed with remarkable fidelity to his plans within two years—no small feat for the era.
The club claims early exhibitions from legends like Harry Vardon, Ted Ray, Walter Hagen, and Bobby Jones, giving members a lasting connection to golf’s golden era. Imagine opening day nerves with four Hall of Famers on the tee.
For over a century, Scarsdale has been a nucleus for passionate Westchester players—competitive, close-knit, and fiercely proud of their club’s Tillinghast pedigree. Walk the fairways and you step straight into club tradition.
Tillinghast’s plans were completed in February 1922 and in play by May 1924—remarkably fast for Golden Age course construction.
Scarsdale describes itself as Westchester County’s second oldest golf course.
The 18th combines two of Willie Dunn’s original holes, reflecting the club’s evolutionary layout.
Historic exhibitions brought together legends like Vardon, Ray, Hagen, and Jones on these fairways.
Clubhouse renovations in 2004 enhanced the century-old architectural charm.
A legendary Tillinghast double course with major history.
Another elite Tillinghast just minutes away.
History, views, and a world-class renovation.
New York’s top public championship venue.
White Plains or a central Westchester hotel for easy access to all the top clubs.
Courses with the most similar DNA profile — matched by deviation shape across all eight playing characteristics.
Why it matches: What links these two? A comparable balance of challenge, variety, and character — a familiar feeling, expressed in Ocean Forest Golf Club's own setting.
Why it matches: Black Bull Golf Club is a natural next stop after Scarsdale Golf Club: it a comparable balance of challenge, variety, and character.
Why it matches: If Scarsdale Golf Club is your kind of course, The Golf Club at Turner Hill is worth a look because it a comparable balance of challenge, variety, and character.
Major championship pedigree
Tillinghast gem nearby
Home of multiple majors
Famous restored classic
Westchester Tillinghast design
Community Sentiment
See something inaccurate in this listing?