Herbert Strong (1904, original), A.W. Tillinghast (1920s remodel), Joe Finger (1970s), Ken Dye (1998–1999), Ron Forse (2013–2015 restoration)
Access
Private
Par
Par 70–71
Length
5,247 – 6,827 yds
The verdict
A Strategic Westchester Gem
Metropolis Country Club stands as a quintessential regionally elite parkland test—walkable, challenging, and rich with historical depth. Its Tillinghast/Strong pedigree has been lovingly restored, delivering an architectural experience that will thrill design aficionados while rewarding disciplined shotmaking.
Course DNA
Difficulty
83
Scenery
72
Conditioning
81
Shot Variety
78
Walkability
79
Green Complexity
82
Wow Factor
74
Design Quality
84
At a glance
Quick facts
Restoration
Ron Forse-led 2013–15 restoration
Region
Heart of Westchester, NY
Bunkers
105 bunkers restored and rebuilt
Historic Tournament
Host of 1940 Metropolitan Open
Course Record
64 (Jack Burke Jr., 1940)
Signature Architects
Herbert Strong, A.W. Tillinghast
Practice Facilities
Driving range, short game area
Vibe
Upscale, member-focused club atmosphere
The design
The architecture
Metropolis is a pure Westchester parkland test refreshed for the modern era—flowing fairways, Golden Age bunkering, and firm greens restored to their Tillinghast/Strong essence. The routing takes full advantage of rolling terrain and the property’s mature trees, while the design challenges you to think on every approach. The recent Forse restoration has softened superficial scars of the past and put bold, era-true hazards back where strategy and aesthetics demand.
Herbert Strong and A.W. Tillinghast combined in both origin and spirit, with modern stewardship ensuring their philosophy endures.
Defining features
Meticulous Golden Age bunkering
Expansive, multi-contour greens
Varied par 3s requiring distance judgment
Integral use of mature Westchester woodland
Classic risk-reward on reachable par 5s
Oblique fairways emphasizing placement
Hole by hole
Signature holes
Hole 1
Invitation to Restraint
PAR
5
YARDAGE
540
The opening hole rewards strategic patience over aggression: a dogleg sweep lined with bunkers and oaks, presenting choices right from the first tee. Driver is tempting, but correct angles reward patience—setting the tone for a cerebral round.
Play it smart
Find the left center of the wide fairway off the tee, lay up short of deep fairway bunkers, and attack the elevated green from a preferred distance.
Where it bites
Over-creativity often finds traps or leaves awkward angles to a perched, well-defended green.
Course management
Shots to think about
Approaching #1 green
Leave a full wedge from short of the cross bunkers for the best spin and control.
Tee shot on #7
Hug the inside corner—risk brings a better angle, but outside is trouble.
Second on #11
Don’t get greedy; position for a comfortable third, avoiding the deep fairway bunkers.
Long approach to #16
Club up and stay below the hole; the green’s back half runs away quickly.
Approach to elevated par 3s
Take enough club for uphill carry and account for swirling wind off the hills.
Driving on mid-length par 4s
Favor placement over length—sidehill lies here can mean half-strokes lost.
On the day
What to expect
Conditions
Firm, fast greens and tight-mown fairways reward sharp iron play, with every bunker freshly restored for architectural bite.
Vibe
Historic, low-key luxury and member camaraderie—modernized amenities, but with an old-school club soul.
Dress code
Traditional private club attire: collared shirts, tailored slacks/shorts; soft spikes only.
Before you tee off
Your game plan
01
Dial in Long Irons
Several long par 3s and mid-to-long par 4s will test your accuracy from 175–210 yards.
02
Short-Game Versatility
The restored bunkers and large greens demand creativity with pitches and sand play.
03
Walk the Course, If Allowed
The routing is enjoyable on foot—if permitted, take a caddie or carry for the best experience.
The lore
How it came to be
1904
Original Herbert Strong course opens
1922
Metropolis Country Club founded
1940
Jack Burke Jr. sets course record (64) at Met Open
Stories & legends
What makes it special
Restoration
The Bunker Renaissance
The restoration led by Ron Forse saw more than 100 bunkers rebuilt or reinstated, returning Metropolis’s fiery defenses to their Golden Age roots. These sculpted hazards now anchor both strategy and beauty throughout the routing.
Tournament History
A Course-Record Moment
In 1940, Jack Burke Jr. blazed to a course-record 64 during the Metropolitan Open, cementing his name in club lore. The round remains a North East touchstone and reminder of the level of play Metropolis has demanded for generations.
Design Philosophy
Undoing Modern Accretions
Late-20th-century changes had smoothed Metropolis’s sharper edges, but the 2010s restoration reversed much of this, recapturing the distinct Tillinghast/Strong style and ensuring today’s course feels both authentic and timeless.
For the group chat
Fun facts
1
Jack Burke Jr.'s 64 in 1940 remains a celebrated club record.
2
The 2013–2015 restoration uncovered and rebuilt more than 100 bunkers.
3
Metropolis was once ranked in Golf Digest's '100 Greatest' (1966).
4
For decades, the club’s identity was shaped by stealthy strength and competitive Met Area lore.
Build the trip
If You're Planning a Westchester Golf Pilgrimage
CourseAccessWhy it's on the listTrip
Bethpage State Park (Black Course)
Municipal
Public access to a major championship layout—brutal and brilliant
Pelham Bay & Split Rock Golf Course
Municipal
Playable public option near NYC with classic bones
Sleepy Hollow Country Club
Private
Iconic Hudson River scenery with Gil Hanse restoration
Westchester Country Club
Private
Prestige setting, strong conditioning
White Plains for easy access to the best Westchester clubs and convenient travel to both public and private standouts.
Course DNA
If You Like Metropolis Country Club
Courses with the most similar DNA profile — matched by deviation shape across all eight playing characteristics.
Community Sentiment
See something inaccurate in this listing?