East Williston, New York
Wheatley Hills offers a sophisticated parkland test with deep roots in Long Island golf history. This is a private club where Devereux Emmet’s routing and decades of tradition shape a round full of thoughtful shot values and local character.
Wheatley Hills captures the essence of early Long Island parkland design, routed over gently rolling, once-farmed terrain with a logical, walkable flow. Devereux Emmet’s influence threads through the layout—classic angles, strategic bunkering, and greens set at subtle cants—complemented by Alfred Tull’s sensitive 1930s re-routing when the property boundaries shifted. The mix of burly par 3s and scorable, decision-laden par 5s produces strong ebb and flow, while mature tree lines, natural undulations, and vestiges of Long Island history give the course both strategic resonance and singular local soul.
Devereux Emmet’s routing still shines, while Alfred Tull’s adaptive 1930s work preserved the course’s character amid change.
A classic par 5 where aggressive tee shots open scoring opportunities but demand precise layup placement. The hole’s length tempts a bold approach, but its subtle doglegs and well-guarded green turn greed into potential disaster with one misstep.
Position the drive for maximum visibility on your layup, then decide whether to chase the green in two or set up a wedge—knowing both misses and angles are perilous.
Penal rough and well-positioned fairway bunkers threaten slicers and hookers alike; over-zealous attacks can lead to awkward third shots under tree cover.
Polished member-club maintenance with classic bentgrass/poa greens; expect smooth, firm surfaces and carefully manicured parkland surrounds.
Steady, unhurried member flow—rounds are rarely rushed but don’t typically drag at private clubs here.
Traditional New York private-club culture, with a refined but welcoming member atmosphere and deep local heritage.
Conservative country-club attire; collared shirts, no denim, and neat presentation required.
Several par 3s and approaches demand confidence with long irons or hybrids—practice these shots before you arrive.
Strategic doglegs and tree-lined corridors reward those who can move the ball both ways—bring your full shot-making arsenal.
Both nines end with stout par 4s; maintain your focus and nerves for the final test.
Wheatley Hills Golf Club incorporated; Devereux Emmet engaged as architect
Full 18-hole course completed
Club purchases land from Titus estate; new clubhouse built
Wheatley Hills’ emblem is the old Titus family farm bell, which still stands guard by the putting green—a living link to the land’s agricultural roots and to a past where a bell signaled time on the farm and now, shots on the tee.
Behind the par-3 third green lie remnants of the historic Long Island Motor Parkway, once a path for early race cars—reminding players that both golf and motoring have left tracks on this legendary ground.
Through farmland, land swaps, and highway constructions, Wheatley Hills has adapted with a respectful sense of place—seen most notably in the 1930s when Alfred Tull’s revisions adjusted for a changing Nassau County landscape.
The 1926 clubhouse, still the centerpiece of Wheatley’s social life, echoes the club’s early-20th-century ambitions and provides the setting for hundreds of memorable member gatherings.
The club’s emblem—the Titus farm bell—still rings beside the putting green.
Remnants of the historic Long Island Motor Parkway run right behind the par-3 third hole.
The 1926 clubhouse remains a central feature and symbol of the club’s classic roots.
The property once operated entirely as farmland, with vestiges still visible in some fairway contours.
A Top-5 public championship course that’s open to all, with major history and the ultimate New York golf test.
Convenient, affordable Nassau County public golf close to Wheatley Hills.
Classic C.B. Macdonald layout with sweeping Sound views—if you can arrange access, don't miss it.
One of Long Island's most storied originals, Emmet’s roots run deep here.
Garden City, Mineola, or Westbury—central Nassau County for easy commutes to nearly every world-class course.
Courses with the most similar DNA profile — matched by deviation shape across all eight playing characteristics.
Why it matches: If Wheatley Hills Golf Club is your kind of course, Marlborough Country Club is worth a look because it a comparable balance of challenge, variety, and character.
Why it matches: What links these two? A comparable balance of challenge, variety, and character — a familiar feeling, expressed in Prairie Green Golf Course's own setting.
Why it matches: There is real overlap here. Biltmore Golf Course a comparable balance of challenge, variety, and character, making it a compelling counterpart to Wheatley Hills Golf Club.
Historic US Open venue, Emmet’s masterpiece
Original design, famed championship venue
Classic Long Island test
Original routing by Emmet
Scenic lakeside original
Community Sentiment
See something inaccurate in this listing?