Osprey Meadows at Tamarack Resort logo
Golf Course Review & Scouting Report

Osprey Meadows at Tamarack Resort

82

Donnelly, Idaho

Established
2006
Architect
Robert Trent Jones II (original and 2024 renovation), Bruce Charlton
Access
Resort
Par
Par 73
Length
3,321 – 5,956 yds
Green Fees
$$$
The verdict

Idaho’s Comeback Mountain Gem

Osprey Meadows is a revived Robert Trent Jones II design that pairs mountain grandeur with player-friendly, championship-caliber golf. Its 2024 renovation delivers striking vistas, improved playability, and strategic interest, making it one of the region’s must-play resort courses.

Course DNA
Difficulty
86
Scenery
91
Conditioning
84
Shot Variety
83
Walkability
66
Green Complexity
80
Wow Factor
81
Design Quality
82
At a glance

Quick facts

Course Status
Reopened in 2024 after major renovation
Mountain Elevation
Over 4,800 feet above sea level
Views
Panoramic vistas of Lake Cascade and the West Mountains
Bonus Hole
Features an extra 19th ‘Gambler’s Hole’
Longest Par 4
No. 3 at 456 yards
Resort Amenities
On-site dining, spa, and adventure sports
Pace of Play
Consistently rated excellent by players
Notable Events
Hosted US Amateur qualifying and PGA sectionals
The design

The architecture

Osprey Meadows is a signature display of Robert Trent Jones II’s modern mountain golf DNA, blending panoramic natural beauty with artfully routed, strategic golf. The 2024 renovation smartly reduced forced carries, expanded fairways, and rebuilt greens while preserving the course's jaw-dropping alpine stage. Every hole frames Idaho's wildness, while repositioned bunkers and recontoured surfaces keep decision-making and shot variety front of mind. The resurrected course showcases Jones’s sophisticated use of elevation, mountain meadows, and water, providing both scenic exhilaration and diverse tests of skill throughout the round.

Robert Trent Jones II and Bruce Charlton brought their strategic mountain-resort ethos to full life here, with Jones personally leading the 2024 restoration.

Defining features
  • Rerouted holes exploiting mountain views
  • Repositioned bunkers and widened fairways
  • Dramatic elevation changes, especially tee-to-green
  • Restored and complex green surfaces
  • Mix of meadow, lakeside, and forested corridors
  • Modern risk/reward par 5s and short par 4s
Hole by hole

Signature holes

Hole 3

High Challenge Dogleg

PAR
4
YARDAGE
456

The longest par 4 on the front, this brawny, scenic dogleg demands a committed drive and a searching approach into a fiercely protected green, usually into the swirling mountain breeze.

Play it smart

Favor accuracy off the tee; missing right is safer but leaves a harder angle. A long iron or wood likely awaits for the approach—trust depth control and commit to your line.

Where it bites

Any miss left brings trees and a tricky recovery; the well-defended green punishes approach shots that drift, demanding both distance and direction precision.

Course management

Shots to think about

Long par 4 into the wind (No. 3)
Prioritize position over power—accept hybrid or fairway wood for a safe layup if needed.
Short risk/reward par 4 (No. 8 or 14)
Gauge your confidence—bold play may pay, but safer club keeps big numbers off the card.
Approach to perched, guarded green
Miss to the best bailout side, and don’t chase tucked pins unless your angle is ideal.
Decision on reachable par 5 (Nos. 7, 16, or 17)
Check wind and lie—commit fully if going for it in two, or lay up to your money wedge spot.
Club selection on short par 3 (No. 2 or 11)
Trust your yardage and commit—short irons often tempt complacency, but these greens demand accuracy.
Bailout after missed fairway in mountain rough
Punch back to safety—don’t risk compounding mistakes in thick or uphill lies.
On the day

What to expect

Conditions

Tour-level mountain greens, restored bunkering, and fairways that hold up to resort play, even post-renovation.

Pace

Efficient and steady for a resort; strong recent reviews on round times.

Vibe

Relaxed but aspirational mountain resort atmosphere—welcoming, polished, and scenic.

Dress code

Standard resort golf attire—collared shirt, proper shorts/pants, golf shoes.

Before you tee off

Your game plan

01

Master altitude adjustments

Expect longer ball flights at over 4,800 feet, so practice clubbing down on full shots.

02

Read mountain greens carefully

Subtle slopes and visual trickery abound; trust your feet over just your eyes.

03

Pack for variable conditions

Mountain weather swings from cool mornings to warm afternoons—bring layers and sun protection.

04

Arrive early for the range

The restored warmup facility lets you groove altitude-adjusted distances before the scenic ride begins.

The lore

How it came to be

  1. 2006

    Osprey Meadows opens, designed by Robert Trent Jones II

  2. 2015

    Voted top public course in Idaho by Golf Digest

  3. 2015

    Course closes after nine years amid resort challenges

  4. 2022

    Major renovation by RTJ II team begins

  5. 2024

    Grand reopening after re-routing and restoration

  6. 2025

    Hosts inaugural Rocky Mountain PGA Pro-Am

  7. 2026

    Hosts US Amateur qualifier and PNGA Senior events

Stories & legends

What makes it special

comeback

The Comeback Mountain

Osprey Meadows famously shuttered just nine years after opening, only to return in greater form after a major restoration. Its transformation from nearly lost gem to Idaho’s acclaimed scenic resort course is a story of golf revival worth the journey.

renovation

Putting Reno to the Test

The 2024 renovation reshaped fairways and greens, reduced forced carries, and opened new play angles while preserving the mountain drama. Players now find risk-reward choices and a balance of challenge and joy in every round.

public-access

Mountain Magic for All

With the public now welcome every day, Osprey offers championship golf without a membership gate. Long hitters, vacationers, and keen strategists alike find themselves tested by a mix of altitude, wind, and sparkling water-lined vistas.

quirk

The Bonus 19th

After the round, don’t miss your shot at the new 19th ‘Gambler’s Hole’—a match-settling playoff challenge that adds an extra burst of fun and tension to resort golf in the Idaho mountains.

For the group chat

Fun facts

1

Reopened in 2024 after a nearly decade-long closure and revival.

2

Features a bonus 19th ‘Gambler’s Hole’ for tiebreakers and fun rounds.

3

Once ranked Idaho’s top public course by both Golf Digest and Golfweek.

4

High elevation means big drives—expect 10–15 yards extra per club.

5

Hosted both a PGA Section Pro-Am and US Amateur local qualifying post-renovation.

Build the trip

Making the Most of Your Idaho Adventure

CourseAccessWhy it's on the listTrip
Jug Mountain Ranch Golf Course
Public

Standout mountain-resort design; memorable scenery and play

Whitetail Club & Resort
Private - Resort Guest Access

Premier golf for a splurge or dual-resort trip

McCall Golf Club
Public

Convenient, fun extra round—multiple nine-hole options

Cascade Golf Course
Public

Nine-hole value, perfect for a laid-back warm-up

Council Mountain Golf Course
Public

Budget-friendly, small-town Idaho experience

Stay at Tamarack Resort for quickest access, or in McCall for varied dining and a full getaway.

Course DNA

If You Like Osprey Meadows at Tamarack Resort

Courses with the most similar DNA profile — matched by deviation shape across all eight playing characteristics.

From the community

Community Sentiment

See something inaccurate in this listing?