Golf Course Review & Scouting Report

Onwentsia Club

82

Lake Forest, Illinois

Forgotten ClassicHistoric architecture that deserves another look.
Established
1895
Architect
Charles Blair Macdonald, Herbert Tweedie, James Foulis, H.J. Whigham, Tom Doak (renovation)
Access
Private
Par
Par 71
Length
5,309 – 6,681 yds
The verdict

Elite Midwest Golf Heritage

Onwentsia Club delivers a storied private-club experience on timeless ground just north of Chicago. Expect wide, playable fairways, sophisticated green complexes, and a palpable sense of golfing tradition. Regionally revered and architecturally distinct, it rewards strategic thinking and honors the legends who shaped it.

Course DNA
Difficulty
79
Scenery
76
Conditioning
84
Shot Variety
80
Walkability
87
Green Complexity
82
Wow Factor
84
Design Quality
87
Don't miss

Catch a glimpse—and if possible, a story—of the annual Pow-Wow tournament, a century-old tradition that defines Onwentsia’s distinctive club spirit.

At a glance

Quick facts

Founding Date
1895
Historic Major Host
1906 U.S. Open
Course Architect
Charles Blair Macdonald & others
State Rank
Golf Digest Best in State
Traditional Annual Event
Pow-Wow since 1906
Longest Hole
3rd hole, 516 yards
Green Fee Access
Members & guests only
Clubhouse Design
Harrie T. Lindeberg, 1928
The design

The architecture

Onwentsia Club is an archetype of Midwestern private-club architecture, weaving together classic strategic principles and the ground-game dynamism that Charles Blair Macdonald brought from his Scottish influences. Its fairways are broad enough to tempt aggressive play, but smart angles and green contours demand constant attention and thoughtful positioning. Tom Doak’s recent renovations have honored and sharpened these original design values, ensuring the course remains a living study in timeless, shot-maker’s golf.

Charles Blair Macdonald, a titan of American course design, instilled enduring strategic themes, layered over time by contributors like Herbert Tweedie and Tom Doak.

Defining features
  • Expansive, deceptively tricky greens
  • Old-school routing with evolving terrain
  • Strategic bunkering that rewards precision
  • Wide fairways that narrow at key angles
  • Ground-game options around putting surfaces
  • Classic Midwest setting with mature trees
Hole by hole

Signature holes

Hole 3

Sweeping Risk-Reward Dogleg

PAR
5
YARDAGE
516

A reachable par 5 that offers early birdie hopes yet punishes misplaced aggression with small-target greens. It tempts long hitters to seize scoring momentum from the very opening stretch.

Play it smart

A well-placed tee shot opens up realistic eagle or easy birdie chances, but angles into the green are everything—keep approaches below the hole for best results.

Where it bites

Getting greedy off the tee or short-siding the approach quickly brings bogey into play.

Course management

Shots to think about

Narrow landing zones on long par 4s
Club down and stay center cut—you won't outmuscle Onwentsia, but accuracy sets up scoring chances.
Approaching angled, bunkered greens
Respect the classic defenses—play to the fat of the green, even if you’re left with a longer putt.
Playing the lengthy par 3s
Embrace your long-iron or hybrid; take confident swings and don’t chase pins tucked near trouble.
Navigating opening scoring holes
Make your birdie runs on the early par 5s; later holes demand more survival than aggression.
Finishing on 18 with a match on the line
Stay present and deliver a committed, composed swing—history rewards the steady closer.
Club selection off the tee
Trust placement over power; most driving zones are designed to reward control and thoughtfulness.
On the day

What to expect

Conditions

Expect tournament-level presentation: lush fairways, smooth greens, and immaculate surrounds as befit a historic private club.

Pace

Efficient, steady pace; member play and private outings keep rounds on schedule except at busiest times.

Vibe

Classic Midwestern restraint—rich in history, understated and friendly, yet anchored in tradition.

Dress code

Strict private-club standards: collared shirts, golf attire, no denim or overly casual clothing.

Before you tee off

Your game plan

01

Brush Up On History

Read up on Onwentsia’s championship roots and Macdonald’s philosophy to appreciate the architecture as you play.

02

Sharpen Long-Iron Play

Prepare for challenging par 3s and long par 4s by tuning up your long-iron and hybrid game.

03

Pack Formal Golf Attire

Dress codes are enforced—bring your classic private-club gear.

04

Make Local Lodging Plans

Lake Forest or Lake Bluff stays minimize drive time and maximize the prestigious North Shore experience.

The lore

How it came to be

  1. 1892

    First holes laid out by Charles Blair Macdonald

  2. 1895

    Onwentsia Club formally established

  3. 1899

    Host to U.S. Amateur Championship

  4. 1906

    Host to the U.S. Open; Pow-Wow tournament founded

  5. 1927

    New clubhouse designed by Lindeberg, opened in 1928

Stories & legends

What makes it special

Club Tradition

The Pow-Wow Tradition

Onwentsia's Pow-Wow tournament, established in 1906, has run continuously for over a century, blending fierce competition with one of the Midwest's oldest golf social gatherings. It's a unique ritual that cements club identity and camaraderie each year.

Course Evolution

From Lawn to Legend

The original course layout began with seven holes on Senator Farwell’s expansive lawn, evolving rapidly to become a model for classic American golf. These humble roots gave way to championship pedigree and a revered club legacy.

Major Moments

1906 U.S. Open Glory

Onwentsia Club etched its name in golf history by hosting the 1906 U.S. Open, seeing Alex Smith claim victory on a course already legendary for its challenge. The tournament cemented the club’s reputation as a cradle of American championship golf.

Women in Golf

Women’s Amateurs at Onwentsia

The club’s embrace of women's championships—including hosting the U.S. Women’s Amateur—reflects a progressive streak in its otherwise traditional DNA. Generations of top amateur golfers have tested themselves on Onwentsia’s strategic ground.

For the group chat

Fun facts

1

Onwentsia hosted the U.S. Open before 40 states had a course.

2

Founded from a seven-hole mansion lawn routing.

3

The annual Pow-Wow event has run since 1906.

4

The 18th green sits in the lingering shadow of a storied 1928 clubhouse.

5

Women’s Amateur tournaments have been held here for over a century.

Build the trip

Top Public and Private North Shore Pairings

CourseAccessWhy it's on the listTrip
Cantigny Golf
Public

Superb public-access option just under an hour away; hosts state-level events.

The Glen Club
Public/Resort

Modern layout with stay-and-play; a favorite fallback for the area.

Medinah Country Club
Private

Major-championship pedigree, world-famous tests.

Shoreacres
Private

Another revered North Shore classic, minutes away.

Strawberry Creek
Public/Resort

Worth the drive north for those extending the trip.

Stay in Lake Forest, Lake Bluff, or Northbrook for the best access to both private and public North Shore clubs.

Course DNA

If You Like Onwentsia Club

Courses with the most similar DNA profile — matched by deviation shape across all eight playing characteristics.

The architect's other work

More from Charles Blair Macdonald

National Golf Links of America

Southampton, NY

A template for strategic American design.

Yale Golf Course

New Haven, CT

Unmatched collegiate course masterpiece.

Sleepy Hollow Country Club

Scarborough, NY

Golden Age gem with Macdonald's hallmark.

From the community

Community Sentiment

See something inaccurate in this listing?