Golf Course Review & Scouting Report

The Tuxedo Club

79

Tuxedo Park, New York

Established
1957
Architect
Robert Trent Jones Sr. (1957), Stephen Kay (renovation, 1991)
Access
Private
Par
Par 71
Length
5,257 – 6,807 yds
The verdict

Heritage and Challenge North of Manhattan

The Tuxedo Club is a regionally elite, historically storied private course with strategic parkland design by Robert Trent Jones Sr. It’s a must-play if you have the invitation—offering both classic shot values and a palpable sense of American golf heritage. While not a cross-country bucket-list stop, its lore and architecture make it a true Northeast standout.

Course DNA
Difficulty
81
Scenery
74
Conditioning
84
Shot Variety
79
Walkability
67
Green Complexity
82
Wow Factor
77
Design Quality
83
Don't miss

Don’t miss the annual Quadrangular Team Matches—a tradition dating back to America’s first interclub match, still played in the club’s original spirit.

At a glance

Quick facts

Course architect
Robert Trent Jones Sr.
Original site opened
1894
Current course opened
1957
Legendary event
Site of first U.S. interclub match (1894)
Notable tournament
Annual Quadrangular Team Matches
Renovation architect
Stephen Kay (1991)
Historic club tradition
Origin of the word 'tuxedo'
Course rating/slope
74/136 (Black tees)
The design

The architecture

The Tuxedo Club’s 1957 Robert Trent Jones Sr. design is a classic parkland routing that weaves through dignified, old-growth landscape. Jones delivers subtly strategic holes, forcing careful positioning off the tee and demanding precision into his penal, well-contoured greens. The course’s variety comes from a smart blend of bold par 4s, strong par 3s and reachable but tactical par 5s—capped by an unforgettable, unconventional closing hole. The overall effect is of a venue built for meaningful competition, yet one rooted in history and tradition.

Robert Trent Jones Sr.'s influence is felt in the sloping greens, bold bunkering, and the relentless demand for intelligent shot placement throughout the round.

Defining features
  • Strong stage-setting opening stretch with par-4s requiring accuracy
  • Penal and imaginative green complexes characteristic of Trent Jones Sr.
  • Risk-reward strategic choices, especially on par 5s and key short par 4s
  • Rolling parkland terrain with classic Northeast hardwoods
  • Clear scoring opportunities balanced with demanding long par 4s
  • Finishing stretch that builds drama to the last green
Hole by hole

Signature holes

Hole 8

The Birdie Gamble

PAR
5
YARDAGE
490

A reachable par 5 that tempts big hitters yet rewards a calculated approach. The tee shot sets up the scorer; the narrow second demands the right angle or leaves a blocked approach. With bunkers and mature trees eyeing errant shots, it's the best chance to seize momentum before the turn.

Play it smart

Prioritize keeping the drive in play over pure distance; aggressive players can chase eagle, but the smart play seeks an open look for the second shot.

Where it bites

Stray right and the trees pinch the angle—misplayed seconds can mean awkward lies, pitching to a narrow green.

Course management

Shots to think about

First tee shot with trees tight on both sides
Favor control over aggression—pick a line with your most reliable club and swing smooth to set the round’s tone.
Mid-length par 3 with wind swirling
Trust the yardage, but always club up if unsure—the green is better long than short.
Aggressive line on the shortest par 5 (8th)
Go bold only if you can clear the trees and favor the right angle in; otherwise lay back for a lofted approach.
Second shot on the par-5 10th
Take the route that leaves your favorite approach number—don’t let bunkers dictate a defensive layup if you can avoid it.
Final drive on the marathon 18th
It’s tempting to go all-out but prioritize fairway and an uphill look for your second—distance matters little if you’re in the rough.
Approach to a pin tucked behind bunkers
Aim for the center of the green and shape gently toward the flag; short-siding is always costly here.
On the day

What to expect

Conditions

Expect immaculate conditioning with tightly mown fairways and fast, true greens; recent upgrades ensure modern surfaces throughout.

Pace

Member play means deliberate yet efficient pace; anticipate a steady round without rush or delay, but exact timing varies by day.

Vibe

Classic, tradition-rich private-club atmosphere with an air of Northeast exclusivity and old-world gentility.

Before you tee off

Your game plan

01

Fine-tune Approach Shots

These greens demand precise distance control and spin—a little practice with wedges and mid-irons will pay off.

02

Pack Classic Attire

The club’s origins gave the world the tuxedo, so dress tradition is serious—bring your best tailored golf look.

03

Expect Competitive Play

Even a friendly round can turn fierce here—be ready for subtle match play tactics and proud locals.

04

Map Your Route

Tuxedo Park is secluded; check drive times and security gate details before you go.

The lore

How it came to be

  1. 1886

    The Tuxedo Club founded as a social and sporting destination

  2. 1894

    Hosts the first interclub golf match in U.S. history

  3. 1957

    Current Robert Trent Jones Sr. course opens after highway construction displaces original layout

  4. 1982

    Annual Quadrangular Team Matches tradition revived

  5. 1991

    Three holes revised by Stephen Kay

  6. 2022

    Major course renovation, including new 9th hole and upgraded bunkers, completed

Stories & legends

What makes it special

History

First Interclub Match

In 1894, The Tuxedo Club hosted the first-ever interclub golf match in the United States—a foundational moment in American golf history that pitted Tuxedo against icons like Shinnecock Hills and St. Andrew's. The event and associated trophy became pivotal in sparking organized competition nationwide.

Reinvention

Highway to Heritage

When the original course was lost to highway construction, The Tuxedo Club responded by moving to a new site and commissioning Robert Trent Jones Sr., ensuring that its championship golf tradition would continue in a modern form.

Tradition

Birthplace of 'Tuxedo'

Beyond golf, the club's name gave the world the term 'tuxedo'—as the local gentry popularized the iconic dinner jacket at the club’s social events, making the club a style legend as well as a sporting one.

Legacy

Quadrangular Renewal

The club revived its classic interclub rivalry in 1982, bringing back the historic Quadrangular Team Matches and connecting modern members to the earliest roots of American golf competition.

For the group chat

Fun facts

1

The club’s name is the origin of the word 'tuxedo' for the iconic black-tie jacket.

2

Tuxedo’s Quadrangular Team Matches are among America’s oldest inter-club competitions.

3

The original course was lost to highway construction and reborn under Robert Trent Jones Sr.

4

Historic clubhouse traditions mingle with top-tier championship golf.

5

Early club rivalries helped inspire USGA trophy design and competition structure.

Build the trip

If you're plotting a golf-rich NYC-area escape

CourseAccessWhy it's on the listTrip
Bayonne Golf Club
Public/Resort

Unforgettable, links-inspired experience open to outside play

Trump National Golf Club Westchester
Semi-Private

Upscale public-access with bold design

Sunningdale Country Club
Private

Classic Westchester prestige just south of Tuxedo

Forsgate Country Club (Banks Course)
Semi-Private

Challenging Raynor-inspired layout with regional acclaim

Sleepy Hollow Country Club
Private

A Golden Age masterpiece—must-play if you can

Suffern, Ramsey, or Mahwah for practical access to the region’s best clubs and the Tuxedo gates.

Course DNA

If You Like The Tuxedo Club

Courses with the most similar DNA profile — matched by deviation shape across all eight playing characteristics.

From the community

Community Sentiment

See something inaccurate in this listing?